A decision guide for round-bale storage
What covering hay is worth
Research checked · Scope: dry hay in large round bales
1. Compare storage methods on the same basis
Dry matter is the hay excluding its water. The comparison below uses one published table throughout, with its storage periods and spring-use condition kept visible. It describes storage losses, not losses during feeding.
Up to 9 months
Used before spring warm-up
- On the ground, covered5 to 10%
- On the ground, exposed5 to 20%
- Elevated on pallets or tires, covered2 to 4%
- Elevated, exposed3 to 15%
- Under an open building2 to 5%
- Enclosed barnless than 2%
12 to 18 months
Longer storage period
- On the ground, covered10 to 15%
- On the ground, exposed15 to 50%
- Elevated on pallets or tires, covered5 to 10%
- Elevated, exposed12 to 35%
- Under an open building3 to 10%
- Enclosed barn2 to 5%
An open endpoint means “less than”. The ranges describe different storage conditions; subtracting their endpoints does not predict what a tarp will save on your farm.
Read the figures as a table
| Storage method | Up to 9 months | 12 to 18 months |
|---|---|---|
| On the ground, covered | 5 to 10% | 10 to 15% |
| On the ground, exposed | 5 to 20% | 15 to 50% |
| Elevated on pallets or tires, covered | 2 to 4% | 5 to 10% |
| Elevated, exposed | 3 to 15% | 12 to 35% |
| Under an open building | 2 to 5% | 3 to 10% |
| Enclosed barn | less than 2% | 2 to 5% |
Source: N1 · Oklahoma State University Extension, Round Bale Hay Storage, BAE-1716, table 2. The short period assumes use before spring warm-up. Weather, bale condition and the storage site affect the result.
Why these figures differ from the Mississippi State table
We use Oklahoma State's original table consistently. Mississippi State P2540 shows 20 to 35% or more for exposed ground storage over 12 to 18 months, and over 2% for short-period enclosed barn storage. Oklahoma State shows 15 to 50% and less than 2%, respectively. We have not combined or averaged the two versions. Compare Mississippi State P2540.
Compare the base as well as the cover. Elevation and covering address different routes for moisture. The ranges overlap in places: they do not establish one fixed percentage saving for every site. Start with your own storage history and local Extension advice when choosing an assumption for a purchase decision.
2. Put a value on the loss you might avoid
Use the value of your own lot at sale or feeding. Keep quantity and unit value on the same moisture basis. Then subtract all additional protection costs, including delivery, base preparation, installation, inspection and repairs, as applicable.
Worked example · first season
Hypothetical inputs, not a savings forecast
These figures are chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not current hay prices, retail tarp prices or observed farm results.
- Hay dry matter in the lot
- 100 US short tons
- Assumed value per dry ton
- $200
- Assumed reduction in storage loss
- 10 percentage points
- Total additional cost, first season
- $800
The tonnage and unit value both refer to dry matter. Convert a price quoted for hay as delivered to the same basis before using it here.
Lot value100 × $200 = $20,000
Gross value preserved, under the assumption$20,000 × 10% = $2,000
Net benefit after protection cost$2,000 − $800 = $1,200
Break-even: 4 percentage points. $800 ÷ $20,000 × 100 = 4. You need to avoid that much storage loss just to cover the assumed cost.
Test a lower saving too. At only 2 percentage points avoided, the gross value preserved is $400. After the same cost, the result is -$400.
The loss reduction is an assumption to justify, not a result read from the chart. This example charges the entire additional protection cost to the first season; it assumes no multi-year tarp life. Changes in feed quality and feeding losses are not valued here. A smaller lot, a shorter storage period or costly site work can change the decision.
Why ground-versus-barn costs are not a tarp return
Mississippi State P2540 gives a historical ground-versus-barn example for a 30-head herd fed for 180 days: 1,200 to 1,600 USD in additional harvested hay costs, or 3,120 to 4,095 USD in purchased hay. These are the publication's example costs, not current prices or savings attributable to a tarp.
Historical context: N1 · Mississippi State University Extension, publication P2540 (POD-04-23). We use a separate, labelled example above rather than treating a barn comparison as the return on a tarp.
3. Give water a way out
A cover can shed rain while the bottom of the stack still takes up moisture. Mississippi State recommends a well-drained site and warns against putting the covering plastic underneath the bales, where water could collect inside it.
Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.
Static view: reduced motion is enabled.Let water leave the stack
- The cover sheds rain.
- A draining support separates bales from wet soil.
- Runoff has a route away from the stack.
Avoid a water-holding pocket
- Wrapping the same sheet under the bales creates a trough.
- Water can collect inside it.
- A cover cannot compensate for a wet base.
Drainage principle and plastic-under-bales warning: N1 · Mississippi State University Extension, publication P2540 (POD-04-23). The drawing does not specify stack dimensions or cover attachment.
Include drainage and support in the cost decision before choosing a tarp. For the cover's width and finished dimensions, use the hay stack size calculator and the guide to hay tarp failure points.
4. Check the hay, not just the calendar
A cover does not repair hay baled too wet. The sources below describe moisture and heating risks, not a universal date on which a stack becomes suitable for covering.
-
Check the hay's condition before covering
Oklahoma State warns that sealing hay above 20 percent moisture under plastic can cause heating, mold and heavy losses. That warning is not a moisture target for baling or a clearance to cover wetter hay after a fixed number of days.
N1 · Oklahoma State University Extension, Round Bale Hay Storage, BAE-1716, Covers section
-
A heating timeline is not a cover date
In its indoor-storage guidance, Illinois Extension reports a usual temperature peak 7 to 10 days after baling and possible monitoring for up to 30 days. These observations do not establish a universal waiting period before tarping a stack.
N1 · University of Illinois Extension, Hay Storage, Storing Hay Inside section
Have the hay's moisture and heating assessed with your local Extension adviser. The condition of the forage is outside a tarp specification.
Questions before buying
How much hay can be lost in outdoor storage?
Oklahoma State's table gives 5 to 20% dry matter loss for exposed round bales on the ground up to nine months, if used before spring warm-up, and 15 to 50% over twelve to eighteen months. These are research ranges under different conditions, not a forecast for a particular stack.
Does the worked example show what my tarp will save?
No. Its inputs are hypothetical. Estimate your own lot value, a defensible reduction in storage loss and the full additional cost of protection. Do not subtract opposite ends of the research ranges and call the result an expected saving.
Should plastic continue underneath the bales?
Mississippi State P2540 warns against continuing the covering plastic underneath the bales because it can form a pocket that holds water. Its guidance calls for a well-drained storage area. The cross-section on this page illustrates that drainage principle.
How long should I wait before covering freshly baled hay?
There is no universal cover date established by the sources used here. Moisture, bale type and heating need assessment. A temperature peak reported in indoor-storage guidance is not a clearance to tarp a stack. Ask your local Extension adviser about the condition of your hay.
First personal reply within 2 business days, with clarifying questions or next steps.