Qualitora LLC, US sourcing partner NM Business ID 7688237 First personal reply within 2 business days

Hay tarp specs and prices, four US vendors compared

All values read on 2026-08-20 from the vendors' own listings. We hold no stock and sell none of these: this is market reference, dated, and it will need re-reading.

The short version. Thickness does not order the prices. On 5 sizes carried by two vendors on the same day, the 16 mil listing was the cheaper one every time, by about twenty percent. At 25 x 54 ft, a 17 mil cover sold as a complete system came within one percent of a 12 mil cover. Their contents differ, so this is not a fabric-only comparison. Recorded grommet spacings of 18, 24 and 36 inches also differ, but those numbers alone do not rank strength or suitability for your stack.

1. The same size, two vendors, two fabrics

Only sizes published by at least two vendors in the recorded sample are listed. A shared nominal size lets us calculate a price gap; it does not establish the same finished size, construction, contents or delivered cost. Percentages below use the thinner listing's price as the comparison base.

Size Thinner listing Thicker listing What the thicker one costs
15 x 54 ft 389.99 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 311.36 USD 16 mil · TarpsPlus 20.2% less Spec sheet →
20 x 48 ft 460.89 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 369.02 USD 16 mil · TarpsPlus 19.9% less Spec sheet →
25 x 33 ft 396.19 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 317.13 USD 16 mil · TarpsPlus 20.0% less Spec sheet →
25 x 54 ft 648.19 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 654.00 USD 17 mil · A1 Tarps, Performer 0.9% more Spec sheet →
28 x 48 ft 645.19 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 516.63 USD 16 mil · TarpsPlus 19.9% less Spec sheet →
33 x 48 ft 760.32 USD 12 mil · Tarp Supply 608.89 USD 16 mil · TarpsPlus 19.9% less Spec sheet →

5 of 6 sizes: the thicker fabric is the cheaper listing. The exception is the pair that sits under five percent apart, where the thicker listing is a complete system rather than a bare cover. It is in the table because hiding it would flatter the finding, and its spec sheet says exactly what it includes.

Prices are shown as displayed on the day, and US tarp vendors display heavy discounting. The underlying source records retain the list-price context. This page does not establish today's discounts or how much of a historical gap came from promotion.

Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.

Static view: reduced motion is enabled.

Same nominal 25 x 54 ft, different offer contents

Historical listings read 2026-08-20. The drawings identify components, not relative quality or an installation method.

Cover listing

Cover-only scope in this comparison Cover

Tarp Supply
12 mil · 7 to 8 oz/yd²
648.19 USD

Cover with its listed edge construction. No complete pipe-and-tension kit established in this offer.

Complete-system listing

More than the sheet is included Cover + components

Read the drawing: blue edges = sleeves; gray bars = PVC pipe sections; orange curve = rope; orange box = tension device. Shapes and positions are symbolic.

A1 Tarps, Performer
17 mil · 7.30 oz/yd²
654.00 USD

Pre-assembled cover with sleeved PVC pipe sections, rope and a tension device. Confirm quantities, supplied parts and instructions.

Construction sources, checked 2026-10-27: Tarp Supply 25×54; A1 Performer 25×54. Prices remain the historical records above, not current quotes or our stock. Confirm finished dimensions and contents before comparing delivered offers. Thickness, weight and grommet spacing alone do not rank performance.

2. What was recorded for each vendor's line

These are the values recorded on 2026-08-20, not current availability or test results. “Not recorded” describes a gap in that dated listing record, not a claim about every product the vendor sells. Open the publisher's page before using a record in a new request.

What is published Tarp Supply Super Duty Poly Hay Tarps TarpsPlus Super Heavy Duty silver/black Tarps Now Hay Tarps Premium A1 Tarps Performer, made by Inland Tarp and Liner
Thickness 12 mil 16 mil 12 mil 17 mil
Fabric weight 7 to 8 oz per square yard 8 oz per square yard not recorded in this listing 7.30 oz per square yard
Grommets solid brass, about every 24 inches aluminium, about every 18 inches number 2 brass spur, every 36 inches not recorded in this listing
Hem and fixing heat sealed seams, rope reinforced hems, corner reinforcement 1/4 inch rope encased in the hem, triangular corner reinforcement polypropylene webbing in the hems, webbing handles around the perimeter sleeved PVC pipes along the length, UV-stable rope, patented tie-down system
Warranty not recorded in this listing not recorded in this listing 1 year extended warranty on materials, workmanship and UV degradation, no duration published
Claimed service life not recorded in this listing not recorded in this listing 3 to 5 years not recorded in this listing
Origin Made in the USA not recorded in this listing imported US manufacturer, plants in Washington, Ohio and Texas
Lead time made to order, 2 to 3 weeks not recorded in this listing not recorded in this listing made to order, up to three weeks

A second Inland system, Bull Flex, is published at 15 mil with a pocket for a user-supplied pipe and a 3 to 5 year service claim. It is on file but not in the table: no size it shares with another vendor was found in this pass, so it would compare nothing. Source: N2 · Inland Tarp and Liner listing, read 2026-08-20

3. The row that is empty everywhere

Thickness 12, 15, 16 and 17 mil, all sold as heavy duty or premium
Fabric weight 7.30 oz, 7 to 8 oz and 8 oz per square yard, and one line publishes none
Material coated woven polyethylene, high density
Grommet spacing 18, 24 or 36 inches depending on the line
Claimed service life 3 to 5 years, where it is claimed at all
Warranty 1 year on one line, one extended warranty with no number attached, and none published on the other two lines
Grab tensile and tear strength not published in the four reviewed listings · No grab tensile or tear result was published in the four listings reviewed on 2026-08-20. Request results for the proposed material with method, edition, specimen and conditions identified. Flatbed vinyl reference values do not establish hay cover performance.

Source: N2 · published listings of Tarp Supply, TarpsPlus, Tarps Now and A1 Tarps, read 2026-08-20

Thickness and weight per area are different measurements: the recorded listings show 7.30 oz at 17 mil and 7 to 8 oz at 12 mil. Confirm both on an identified sample before production where possible, then agree reception checks. Neither value alone ranks durability or proves the delivered material.

Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.

Static view: reduced motion is enabled.

Measure the property you are specifying

Fabric weight per area

Use the mass and area of an identified fabric specimen Known area mass

Specimen mass ÷ specimen area. Keep the area units consistent with g/m² or oz/yd². Identify the proposed finished fabric, including its coating where specified.

Agree the specimen, conditioning, method and tolerance before taking a sample. This drawing is not a sampling protocol or a test result.

Thickness

Thickness measures between the fabric faces Thickness only

Mil describes thickness. It does not convert into a fabric weight without other material information. Agree the measurement method separately.

The section is enlarged for explanation. Neither its drawn thickness nor its color represents one of the compared offers.

Whole-cover weight

A complete cover includes more than the fabric specimen Fabric + construction

Useful for handling and an agreed screening check. Hems, reinforcement and hardware contribute to the total. It does not establish the fabric's weight per area.

Compare the approved construction and the identified specimen separately. No resistance or service life is inferred from these measurements.

Conceptual measurements, not to scale. Record buyer requirements, supplier confirmation and received-batch evidence separately.

4. What the covering is worth, from published research

The prices above are only half a decision. The other half is what a cover saves, and that one is not a vendor claim: it is extension research, published with its method.

Published storage loss table
Large round bales: percent dry matter loss
Storage methodUp to 9 months12 to 18 months
On the ground, covered 5 to 10% 10 to 15%
On the ground, exposed 5 to 20% 15 to 50%
Elevated on pallets or tires, covered 2 to 4% 5 to 10%
Elevated, exposed 3 to 15% 12 to 35%
Under an open building 2 to 5% 3 to 10%
Enclosed barn less than 2% 2 to 5%

Source: N1 · Oklahoma State University Extension, Round Bale Hay Storage, BAE-1716, table 2. The short period assumes use before spring warm-up. Weather, bale condition and the storage site affect the result.

Why these figures differ from the Mississippi State table

We use Oklahoma State's original table consistently. Mississippi State P2540 shows 20 to 35% or more for exposed ground storage over 12 to 18 months, and over 2% for short-period enclosed barn storage. Oklahoma State shows 15 to 50% and less than 2%, respectively. We have not combined or averaged the two versions. Compare Mississippi State P2540.

Mississippi State P2540 gives a historical ground-versus-barn example for a 30-head herd fed for 180 days: 1,200 to 1,600 USD in additional harvested hay costs, or 3,120 to 4,095 USD in purchased hay. These are the publication's example costs, not current prices or savings attributable to a tarp. Mississippi State also warns: Do not put the plastic underneath the bales: water could pool inside the cover.

Historical example and drainage warning: N1 · Mississippi State University Extension, publication P2540 (POD-04-23)

Method, and what this page cannot tell you

  • Read-only pass on 2026-08-20. No vendor was contacted, no sample was measured, nothing here was tested by us.
  • Prices are as displayed that day, discounts included, with the list price recorded in each source line. Re-read them before quoting anything against them.
  • Only sizes published by two or more vendors are compared. Single-vendor sizes are on file and excluded on purpose.
  • Thickness in mil and fabric weight in ounces per square yard are two different measurements. Neither is a substitute for the other, and no vendor publishes a conversion.
  • The 25 x 54 ft pair is not fabric against fabric: the thicker listing includes pipes, rope and a tension system. Its spec sheet says so.
  • No search volume, no market share, no sales figures. This page compares what is published, and nothing else.

Questions this page answers

Does a thicker hay tarp cost more?

Not consistently in this dated sample. On 5 compared sizes with a price gap of at least five percent on 2026-08-20, the thicker listing was cheaper every time, by about twenty percent. Offer contents also differ. Thickness alone does not rank price or performance.

Which thicknesses appear in this dated sample?

The recorded lines include twelve, fifteen, sixteen and seventeen mil, under words like heavy duty, super heavy duty or premium. Those labels do not define a common performance class. Recheck the proposed material, finished dimensions and included parts before comparing offers.

How far apart should hay tarp grommets be?

The three recorded spacings are eighteen, twenty-four and thirty-six inches. The listings reviewed do not establish which spacing suits a particular stack or wind exposure. Agree the hem, reinforcement, fixing system and intended use together; spacing alone does not establish edge-assembly strength.

What tensile strength does a hay tarp have?

The four listings reviewed on August 20, 2026 did not publish grab tensile or tear results. This is a gap in that sample, not evidence that hay tarps cannot be tested. Request results for the proposed fabric with an identified method, edition, specimen and conditions; a flatbed vinyl reference is not a result for polyethylene hay cover fabric.

What these numbers mean when you buy: hay tarps, specified where they actually fail. Diagnose fabric, edge and water-path problems: where hay tarps fail. What covering is worth on your own numbers: what covering hay is worth.

First personal reply within 2 business days, with clarifying questions or next steps.