Where hay tarps fail, and what to check
For buyers of covers for dry hay stacks. Content reviewed October 27, 2026; vendor comparisons retain their original reading date.
What do you see, and what should you check?
Use this buyer checklist to frame the investigation. A visible symptom can have several causes. Inspect the cover and storage setup before choosing a replacement or assigning a cause.
| Visible symptom | Possible causes | What to ask for | Evidence to agree |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eyelet or edge torn out | Movement at a fixing point, damaged reinforcement or a mismatch with the cover system. | Hem layers, eyelet positions, corner detail and the applicable instructions. | Photos of the damaged area and an agreed sample test of the proposed edge assembly. |
| Hole or wear patch at a contact edge | Repeated rubbing against an exposed edge or an existing damaged surface. | Contact locations, edge protection and material suitable for that use. | A labeled contact sketch, condition photos and an agreed sample inspection. |
| Water appears near a seam | A damaged seam or a leak nearby; visible water alone does not locate its entry point. | Seam construction, repairs and the agreed water-resistance check. | Locate where water enters; compare a sample with the agreed seam and test method. |
| Water collects in a low pocket | A low cover profile, changed fit or a drainage route that holds water. | Actual stack profile, usable cover size and where runoff should leave. | Profile and runoff photos, finished dimensions and the cover maker’s instructions. |
| Damp hay under an intact cover | Moisture already in the hay, ground moisture or trapped moisture; a fabric tear is not required. | Hay condition, storage period, base drainage and intended ventilation. | Assess the hay and storage conditions with local agricultural advice; inspect the base as well as the sheet. |
Editorial checklist informed by the practitioner accounts and storage guidance below. These are possible checks, not measured failure frequencies or a diagnosis of a particular stack.
For a fit or water-pocket problem, start with the measured stack profile and confirm the finished cover dimensions.
How can a changed stack profile affect the cover?
A grower describes a cover working loose, flapping in wind and suffering damage at its fixing points. This account raises questions about changed fit and edge construction; it does not establish a universal failure sequence.
Paraphrase of an individual practitioner account: N3 · grower post, Hay & Forage Forum, 2018-12-02, paraphrased. It illustrates a possible mechanism, not a verified quotation, a time to failure or a service-life forecast.
Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.
Static view: reduced motion is enabled.Stack settlement can change the fit
A lower or changing profile can leave a different amount of cover over the stack.
Movement can reach the edge
Growers report slack, flapping and damage at fixing points. Other failure paths are possible.
Ask how the proposed cover system accommodates the actual profile and changes during storage. Record its inspection and maintenance instructions with the order.
What sits behind the fixing point?
The eyelet, surrounding sheet, hem and reinforcement belong in the same construction detail. Rope-reinforced hems, webbing-reinforced edges and sleeve systems are different assemblies. Ask the supplier to identify the one proposed.
Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.
Static view: reduced motion is enabled.Locate the fixing point
An eyelet is only the visible part. Ask which layers surround it and where it sits in the finished edge.
Ask what is inside the hem
A folded edge may contain rope or webbing. Specify the proposed reinforcement, joins, corners and the eyelet position. This drawing shows a webbing example.
Identify a sleeve system separately
A tube inside a sleeve is another construction. Ask for the complete system details and its instructions; a reused sheet with a pipe is not automatically equivalent.
These drawings identify parts to discuss. Strength depends on the complete construction and relevant test evidence. More eyelets or a thicker sheet do not by themselves establish assembly performance.
What should you measure before choosing a hay tarp?
Use the actual pile as your reference. For square bales or an irregular pile, send a labeled profile instead of selecting a round-bale pyramid by guesswork.
Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.
Static view: reduced motion is enabled.Measure the surface, not just the footprint
The cover follows a longer route over the pile. Measure over the actual stack to the intended cover edges.
Record the bale dimensions, row arrangement, stack length and intended coverage at both ends.
Send the measured span with a labeled profile. It gives the supplier a fit question to answer.
The round bale stack calculator models a tight pyramid of equal, circular bales and shows a geometric span alongside dated vendor charts. Flattened bales, gaps and settlement change the surface. Compare the model with your measurement; a result close to a nominal tarp width does not establish a fit.
| Request field | What to record | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Stack profile | Bale type, actual dimensions and row arrangement. | It defines the surface the cover follows. |
| Surface span | Measured distance over the stack to the intended cover edges. | A footprint width is not a cover width. |
| Length and ends | Stack length and the intended coverage at both ends. | End allowances differ between vendor guides. |
| Repeated stacks | Quantity and a separate sketch for each differing profile. | One cover specification may not fit every pile. |
N2 example of differing sizing instructions: Mytee Products' hay size selector, read October 3, 2026, asks for actual bale measurements and specifies its own end allowance. Its guide is not the allowance used by every cover system. The calculator retains its separately sourced rule and identifies it in the result.
Which size will you actually receive?
Ask whether the quoted size is a cut size or a finished size. Have the supplier confirm the outside dimensions after hemming and the agreed tolerances, then compare those dimensions with the cover needed for your measured stack.
Conceptual illustration. You can pause the movement.
Static view: reduced motion is enabled.Cut sheet
The sheet before the edges are folded.
Finished cover
Measure between the outer finished edges, including the hems.
Which storage conditions belong in the request?
State the expected storage period, base and drainage condition, exposed edges, intended ventilation and existing cover system. Include the cover maker's installation instructions if you are replacing a known system. Ask how the proposed hem and fixing arrangement works with that system; do not substitute a universal tension recipe.
Oklahoma State's Round Bale Hay Storage explains that moisture, climate, storage duration and the site affect losses. Its covering method weights edges and permits some movement; it also warns against sealing high-moisture hay under plastic.
The manufacturer's instructions for round-bale Performer covers describe checking and retightening that particular system. These are different arrangements. Use the instructions applicable to the proposed cover rather than a universal tension recipe.
This worksheet prepares a cover specification. It does not decide whether hay is ready for storage or design a wind-resistant installation. Those questions need the applicable cover instructions and local agricultural or site advice. For drainage diagrams and the storage comparison, see what covering hay is worth. Keep any expected loss reduction separate from a product promise.
What the dated vendor listings say about the edge
| Vendor and line | Grommets | Hem and fixing |
|---|---|---|
| Tarp Supply Super Duty Poly Hay Tarps | solid brass, about every 24 inches | heat sealed seams, rope reinforced hems, corner reinforcement |
| TarpsPlus Super Heavy Duty silver/black | aluminium, about every 18 inches | 1/4 inch rope encased in the hem, triangular corner reinforcement |
| Tarps Now Hay Tarps Premium | number 2 brass spur, every 36 inches | polypropylene webbing in the hems, webbing handles around the perimeter |
| A1 Tarps Performer, made by Inland Tarp and Liner | not published in the recorded listing | sleeved PVC pipes along the length, UV-stable rope, patented tie-down system |
Vendor declarations recorded on 2026-08-20, not sample measurements or confirmation of current specifications. The comparison names competing lines without product links.
The recorded spacings differ. A smaller spacing alone is not proof of a stronger assembly; the exact eyelet count also depends on edge length and end positions. Record locations, count and surrounding construction together. For wider context, see the dated specs and prices comparison.
So what do you write on the order?
Send the profile, measured surface span, finished dimensions and tolerances, quantity, proposed material and edge construction. Attach the relevant installation and maintenance instructions. Then agree how conformity will be checked.
- Material, thickness and weight per area against the order. Thickness and weight per area measure different properties. Agree the measurement method and any sample cutting before inspection.
- Grommet count and spacing against the order. Record positions, count and the surrounding edge construction. Spacing alone does not establish assembly strength.
- Hem and corner construction against an agreed sample. Identify reinforcement, joins and fixing positions. Open a hem only on a sample agreed for that purpose.
- Edge-assembly tests agreed before production. Practitioner accounts identify damage at fixing points as a question to investigate. A destructive test needs an agreed specimen, method, direction, sample quantity and acceptance threshold.
- Finished dimensions against the measured stack profile. Record usable size, tolerances and intended edge coverage. The ground footprint does not describe the surface the cover follows.
Assess the fabric, seams, reinforced edges and proposed cover system together. Keep installation and maintenance instructions with the specification; thickness alone is not a performance guarantee.
For destructive tests, agree the specimen location, test direction, method, sample quantity and acceptance threshold before production. Include the treatment of a nonconforming result. Opening a hem also belongs on an agreed sample; do not cut delivered covers without a plan.
What the evidence can tell you
- The practitioner summaries are questions to investigate. They do not establish a failure rate, a universal sequence or a product lifetime.
- The four vendor records do not provide comparable tensile or tear test reports for the proposed complete assembly. Ask for the method and scope of any evidence offered.
- Wind loading on a covered stack is site engineering. We specify the cover and what holds it; we do not certify that any assembly will hold in a given wind.
Questions
What actually makes a hay tarp fail?
Start with the visible symptom: damage at the edge, contact wear, a suspected seam leak or a water-holding pocket need different checks. Practitioner accounts describe slack and fixing-point damage as one possible mechanism. They do not establish which failure is most common or a universal sequence.
Is a thicker hay tarp a better hay tarp?
Thickness and weight per area measure different properties. Neither alone ranks different materials, seams and edge assemblies by durability. Ask for the construction and relevant test evidence for the proposed cover.
How far apart should the grommets be?
Use the requirements of the proposed cover system. The dated listings below show different spacings; spacing alone does not establish strength. Record the number, positions, hem construction and installation instructions before ordering.
Are recycled billboard covers a real option?
Practitioners report using recycled sheets, but their condition and construction vary. A sheet with a pipe is not automatically equivalent to a specified sleeve system. Check the material condition, edge construction, usable size and applicable instructions.
Should a hay tarp always be pulled tight?
Follow the instructions for the particular system. A weighted covering method that permits movement and a purpose-built system that requires checking and retightening are different arrangements. Do not transfer a tension instruction from one to the other.
Practitioner sources and reading limits
Historical reading dates are retained below. Direct access to the main forum threads was unavailable during the October 27, 2026 review; the account above is presented as a paraphrase. Archived material does not establish current product performance.
- Hay & Forage Forum: what kind of tarps are best for hay?
2020-07 to 2024-05, read in full 2026-08-20. Practitioner testimony. - Hay & Forage Forum: what's the scoop on hay tarps?
2018-12 to 2019-02, read in full 2026-08-20. Practitioner testimony. - Hay & Forage Forum: hay tarps
2020-02, read in full from archived PDF 2026-08-21. Practitioner testimony. - Hay & Forage Forum: storing hay under a tarp
2013-10 to 2013-11, read in full from archived PDF 2026-08-21. Practitioner testimony.
Next: what covering hay is worth, and the family page, hay tarp family and published formats.
First personal reply within 2 business days, with clarifying questions or next steps.
Watch the explanation
Visit our YouTube channelVideos in English. Playing a video connects to YouTube.